Tag Archives: Hall

Leeds United: Loan Signings Review…plus their futures at Elland Road

Ahead of their contracted final game for Leeds (against Hull City), we are reviewing the contribution of the loanees to the ups and downs of Leeds United thus far this season:

Michael Tonge: Arguably the most important of the loan signings we have made this season, Tonge has been an important creative force in the center of a midfield that lacked one when the season began. Derided when shoved out to the left hand side of midfield, where he was lost and ineffective, Tonge was, with the arrival of fellow loanee Jerome Thomas, able to move back into the center, where he has since proven his effectiveness. Able to pinpoint a pass, something his fellow midfielders often seem entirely unable to do, Tonge could be seen as key to the upturn in form since Thomas’s arrival. Has also scored some useful goals in the context of the season. Must admit, got this one completely wrong at first. Whilst he has already gone back to his parent club, Tonge has no future at Stoke and will almost certainly be signed permanently in January. Done a good job, would not blame Warnock for signing him – 6/9.

Jerome Thomas: As much as we thought he was after Crystal Palace, sadly Jerome Thomas is not Max Gradel. Flatters to deceive at times, but with a run in the side and a lack of injuries could turn out to be a really good player at this level. Time is not on his side though, with only one game left to run on his initial loan. If I were speaking to him one-on-one, I would recommend attempting to manoeuvre a permanent transfer, as he is likely a step below what is required at the upper end of the Premier League (which, it must be remembered, is where West Brom are plying their trade this year). Whilst he has seemed ‘off’ in many games, the statistics do not lie: played 7, won 5; two assists and a goal. Sign him up – 12/14.

Alan Tate: The last two games have been unkind to Tate in my eyes – where Pearce would likely have battled and scared Middlesbrough’s hulking striker, Tate allowed himself to be trampled. Looked calm and assured in the first few games of his loan however, and it may just be a blip. At the very least, we certainly need a third center back of some quality – Paddy Kisnorbo proved last year that he cannot and should not come into contention for first team football at any point this season, and word on the streets suggests Leigh Bromby would be lucky to walk properly ever again, never mind play football. Disappointed recently, but can still go on to make himself a solid feature in the rest of the season, should he be signed – 1.7/3.

Not mentioned: Ryan Hall (already signed permanently for a reported £150,000). Hall, 24, has been pointed to as a player of ‘potential’ by Warnock, which makes sense, given that Warnock seems to consider players to be in their peak well into their thirties.

Ultimately, the loanees have been imperative to some of our successes and have generally avoided being tarred with the brush of our failures. All three deserve signing, whether permanently or until the end of the season. They will certainly provide more to Leeds in the second half of the season than the likes of Varney, Connolly, Gray etc.

Follow Amitai Winehouse on Twitter (@awinehouse1).

Leeds United: First January Signing Confirmed, Who Next?

Leeds United have today confirmed the signing of Ryan Hall on a two and a half-year deal, with Neil Warnock pointing to the potential of the winger as a future star as reason behind the signing. This either makes complete sense or none at all – Hall is already aged twenty-four, by which time most with ‘potential’ who are worth keeping are demonstrating their value. One saving grace for Hall is his performances for Southend last season, where he led League Two’s assist charts, something imperative for a team that should be built around providing crosses for Luciano Becchio. First team football needs to come soon at Elland Road for Hall, however, and it would not be ridiculous to suggest Hall and Thomas on opposite wings might be an interesting, if not defensively unsound, idea.

Who is to come in next? The signings of Alan Tate and Michael Tonge are all but confirmed, with neither of them needed at their actual clubs and Warnock seemingly a huge fan of both. I’m more reticent to back the signing of Tate than Tonge, as, where Tonge improved over the course of his loan spell, Tate has looked increasingly shaky in the past two games against Middlesbrough and Nottingham Forest, especially failing to deal with Lukas Jutkiewicz. Both will likely be into Leeds soon enough.

Where Jerome Thomas is concerned, it seems slightly more tricky. Word from West Brom is that they are less keen to sell than Stoke and Swansea are, and it might actually take some money to sign a player who, at first, seemed the answer to all of Leeds’s woe. His fitness issues have cropped up recently, and he has seemed far less effective since his rip-roaring appearances against Crystal Palace and Leicester. If an alternative is available, it might be them we see on the left-wing after January.

Warnock has pointed to a need to sign a striker in January, but with Becchio, McCormack, Diouf and the returning Somma at his disposal, there have been questions as to how necessary this truly is. However, Leeds have been linked to several, not least Rickie Lambert by the derided and regularly incorrect Daily Mail. Unlikely and would be immensely surprising.

Max Gradel is a hope for most, but it is worth pointing out that his form in the second half of last season carried St. Ettiene to the Europa League, and he has also been linked to Liverpool ahead of January. He has still been playing regularly for the French side. Even if Gradel loves the club, would he be willing to return to such a relatively low level?

Follow Amitai Winehouse on Twitter (@awinehouse1).