Leeds United: Let’s be realistic about O’Leary

By Dominic Smith

I can’t blame Leeds fans for wanting David O’Leary back, however daft the idea seems.

It was, after all, under O’Leary that we enjoyed our finest years in the (relatively) modern era. Now
that it’s almost ten long years since we were last in the Premier League, and twelve since THAT
Champions League run, it’s that O’Leary side that represents the best that a sizeable group of our
fans have seen, myself included.

As a 23 year old, I don’t remember the great 1991/2 title winning side, and have only hazy memories
of seeing the likes of Strachan and McAllister strut their stuff in our midfield. As difficult as it is to
admit now, my childhood heroes were the likes of Lee Bowyer and Harry Kewell. It was that O’Leary
side that I loved so much, whose posters adorned my walls, who represented all that was good
about our club. The gutsy heroism of Radebe, the grit of Barry, the trickery and pace of Kewell, the
cool finishing of Viduka. It’s embarrassing, knowing what we do now about the corrosive behaviour
in the boardroom, and how so many of those players disgraced themselves after leaving the club.

But my generation still look back on that period with so much fondness. Years of abject
performances make us long for that time again, when finishing 4th in the Premier League was
deemed a failure.

And it’s not simply nostalgia. Who can blame fans for wanting to relive the better days when there
is simply no future vision for the club? We have owners who seem desperate to flog the club a bit
at a time, a recently departed manager who kept telling us he wanted to leave, and a bunch of new
players accustomed to the nomadic lifestyle of being second-rate journeymen.

How different to how it was under O’Leary. Young players were plucked from the Academy and
shone in the first team, complimented by wise old heads like Nigel Martyn. The fans, players
and management were all seemingly united in a modern vision of Leeds United, playing exciting,
attacking football. We took on the giants of Europe and beat them. Who can forget the last-minute
victory against AC Milan or the humbling of Anderlecht?

But we have to take off these rose-tinted glasses. We won’t progress as a club by trying to relive
the old days. The great Revie side were thrust into management, one by one, in the 1980s, to try
and bring some success back to the club. Bremner, Clarke and Gray, all legends, failed, because of
financial mismanagement and no vision for how we moved forward as a club.

And don’t forget O’Leary’s part in our demise. He oversaw a ludicrously imbalanced and bloated
squad, signing the likes of Robbie Fowler and Seth Johnson for crazy fees on inflated wages,
made increasingly bizarre statements to the press and wrote a book when he should have been
concentrating on our stuttering on-field performances.

Not even considering the fact that O’Leary has been out of serious management for seven years, his
return would be a bad mistake. We cannot move forward as a club by reliving the past.

Follow Dominic Smith on Twitter (@DomoTheBold).


8 thoughts on “Leeds United: Let’s be realistic about O’Leary”

  1. I’ve said a thousand times, O’leary wasn’t a good manager. He underachieved with a wealth of talent at his disposal, very poor tactically. He didn’t do anything extraordinary at leeds, all the foundations were laid by Howard Wilkinson, who brought in all the young players used by O’leary, and should have remained manager himself, he would have built a team capable of actually winning the title. Also the 91/92 side was not a ‘great’ team by any means, functional and with a good midfield, but average everywhere else. The only great team Leeds have had was under the Don, and we will never have one again unless rich arab gets bored and wants to throw some millions into a club

  2. Having been a life long leeds fan who totaly supports my club i have to agree with some of the comments placed However, we have to take into account that we as Leeds Fans always think we are better than we actually are, the fact is unless we spend time, efort and logical financial spending on our youngsters and quality players instead of buying journeymen we will never reach any where near the hieghts of previous generations. the past is the past and we need to look forward and build a financial plan for success, this has to be agreed at base route level and include the development of out young stars, build on stability, development, training and skills. The manager who ever he may be has to have the understanding of what a team and Fans like Leed United expect and demand, this club is built on a fantastic fan base and the ties to teh fans expectations is high a manager who does not or cannot comprehend will always suffer and struggle to acheive what is expected, therein lies the problem. The board needs to except the manager will not acheive things quickly and let them set a realistic time frame for success and not demand immediate promotion or even succes, this places to much onto any managers thinking and strategy, managers such as O Leary for example do have the knowledge of what we as a club are all about, this does nto mean his is the man but his understanding, Knoweledge and passion for the club are the kind of ingredients needed for this role.

  3. Let’s get bakke and Kelly to step in or batty and Matteo or maybe even Jesus cos he the only one who can sort out the mess NW has left

  4. Being a 23 year old Leeds fan myself, I can relate to this post. I began supporting Leeds under O’Leary, and those players Dom mentioned were also my heroes, at the time at least.
    But we differ on one point. I actually do believe that O’Leary would be a good choice. He played attractive football, used the youngsters and got some decent results.

    OK, he didn’t win anything, but Fergie didn’t win anything in the first 6 years at Old Trafford, O’Leary got 4 years at Elland Road.

    Give him the job, and have him leashed by a financially shrewd director of football, and glory might return to Elland Road, I say.

Leave a Reply